Tag: Dinner in New Buffalo Search Search No Records FoundSorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again. Google Map Not LoadedSorry, unable to load Google Maps API. Brewster’s Italian Cafe No Reviews Favorite Address: 11 W. Merchant Street New Buffalo Michigan 49117 Telephone: 269-469-3005Email: abagail@brewstersitaliancafe.comWebsite A beautiful, locally owned restaurant located in downtown New Buffalo, Michigan; Brewster’s Italia Read more...