All Galleries in New Buffalo Search Search No Records FoundSorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again. Google Map Not LoadedSorry, unable to load Google Maps API. One Cottage Way No Reviews Favorite Address: 45 S. Whittaker St New Buffalo Michigan 49117 Telephone: 833-629-4968Website We’re excited to announce the opening of our One Cottage Way Home Goods & Gifts shop in New Buffalo, MI! Read more... The Hidden Gem No Reviews Favorite Address: 122 North Whittaker Street New Buffalo Michigan 49117 Telephone: 269-469-8060 Gift shop in the heart of downtown New Buffalo – find unique finds, artists creations, cards, and jewelry for every Read more...